False pretense: Tips to help dealerships spot it and stop it.
Theft by false pretense doesn’t require a break-in. It happens when a criminal uses deception — often a scheme or stolen identity — to convince your team to hand over a vehicle, keys or parts.
False pretense commonly includes fake, stolen or altered IDs; misrepresented personal or financial information; attempts to bypass standard steps; and pressure to deliver before paperwork and funding are fully verified. Many offenders may be prepared with research on your store, staff names, hours and sales approach to sound credible.
The risk is growing.
According to the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NCIB), the use of identity theft in insurance crime was expected to rise by 49% at the end of 2025 once all information is analyzed. The US Federal Trade Commission reports that financial losses associated with fraud increased 32% in 2025 to $15.9B, up from $12B in 2024.¹
The key takeaway: training and consistency are some of your best defenses.
Review each phase of your transaction process and identify where shortcuts happen and risks can be greatest.
MEET & GREET:
When the red flags show up first.
Rapport matters — but so does awareness. Watch for customers who:
- Claim an appointment that can’t be confirmed
- Name-drop leaders or claim personal relationships
- Ask for exceptions “just this once”
- Seem unusually agreeable with no questions, no negotiation or no normal decision-making
- Arrive near closing and push for a rushed delivery
- Try to change your process (different forms, skipping steps)
Coach your team to notice behavior that feels too familiar, rehearsed answers, fast trust-building or unusual nervous movements such as fidgeting or cautious handling of documents. Support staff to slow down, follow the process and escalate concerns without fear of losing the deal.
Identification checks:
Your strongest early control.
Based on claims data, fake or stolen IDs are a leading driver of false pretense losses. Verify identity before test drives, credit/financing steps and any vehicle release.
Best practices:
- Confirm the customer matches the photo and physical description
- Confirm the ID is valid and unexpired
- Copy/store the ID per policy and legal guidelines
- Use at least two forms of identification
- Compare signatures across documents
- Ask the customer to verbally confirm key details (name, birthdate, address)
- Use conversational follow-ups to check consistency
- Use an ID scanner for added deterrence and detection
Any inconsistency should trigger a pause and leadership review.
Credit application:
Look for mismatches — not just approval.
A credit app helps validate identity only if it’s reviewed properly. Watch for:
- Incomplete applications
- Unverified or questionable addresses
- Details that don’t match the credit report or employer information
If anything doesn’t line up, verify the address, confirm employment when appropriate and collect any additional documentation required by policy.
F&I:
Never release early.
This is where criminals may apply pressure. The goal is urgency — so your team skips a step and delivers a vehicle without a complete, enforceable deal.
Key controls:
- Work with known, trusted financial institutions, especially for third-party financing
- Complete paperwork before release
- Verify all identity and financial details (SSN, DOB, address, etc.)
- Run required credit checks on all customers
- Confirm funds are received and verified before delivery
- Scrutinize cashier’s checks and wire transfers
No matter how “certain” the sale feels, don’t deliver the vehicle until the deal is complete and verified.
Training:
A simple way to reduce costly mistakes.
Training improves consistency and helps employees spot red flags and protect inventory:
- Cover false pretense in new-hire onboarding
- Provide annual refreshers for all staff
- Add periodic spot-check coaching using real scenarios and current fraud trends
For more information regarding best practices, please contact: ADILossControl@ally.com
Full service
Solutions and support for every inch of your dealership and beyond.
Ally provides a full suite of products and services delivered by a stacked team that’s here to help every step of the way.